favorite this post $200 / 3br - Keuka LAKE FRONT Cottage: Spring + Fall Dates Available (East Lake Road, Penn Yan, NY) hide this posting unhide

East Lake Road near Second Milo

(google map)

3BR / 1Ba available may 27

no laundry on site
no smoking
off-street parking



We still have availability on the below dates! Please email with some information about who would be staying at the cottage and a little about yourself. It's a quiet spot and we like our neighbors (!) so we always like to know a bit about who will be renting!

LOW SEASON (May - June/September - October): $200/night: 4-night minimum
*Monday PM, May 27 - Monday, June 3 AM
*Tuesday PM, June 11 - Friday AM, June 14
*Tuesday PM, June 18 - Monday, June 24 AM
*Tuesday PM, September 3 - Monday, October 14

Rental vacancies starting at the end of May! Perfect for 1-2 families to share and enjoy lake access on one of the most pristine Finger Lakes in the region. Keuka Lake is widely known for its large fish population, clean waters, friendly ducks and beautiful swimming water.

The cottage is a summer, rustic cottage tastefully and simply decorated with all the amenities you need, but not too many to be distracting! It's been a family summer cottage for almost 100 years (in 2022). Don't worry, we've fixed the leaks in the roof since our days of putting pots and pans in the living room to catch the water. However, it is a cottage and not a villa or chalet! It was built by our great grandmother and is a summer cottage. An occasional friendly spider is not unusual, but can be ushered out without an issue. :-)


Spend your days sitting on the dock, fishing, reading, doing puzzles, playing games inside or BBQing. We spend full weeks at the cottage and only leave to go to the grocery store or get worms for fishing!

You can also take advantage of the many attractions the finger lakes has to offer - from day trips to Ithaca and Buttermilk Falls to Keuka and Seneca Lake wine trails. This is in Amish country where you can enjoy fresh fruit stands and the best sweet corn in the state when in season.



3BR/1BA in the main cottage:
*BR#1: lake-view, off the front porch, full-size bed.
*BR#2: off the living room, sliding barn doors for privacy, full-size bed.
*BR#3: off the living room, sliding bard doors for privacy, twin-bunk beds.
*BA#1: off the living room, stand-up shower.

Room Over the Boathouse
*BR#4/Bonus Room: There are also 2 twin beds in the room over the boathouse near the water. The boathouse is separate from the main cottage and is one large room. You have to exit and walk up to the main cottage to use the bathroom. It's perfect for teenagers and more privacy (we used to fit up to 11 cousins down there)!

Fully functional and equipped kitchen at your disposal. Gas grill, dishes and silverware are there for your use.

The cottage is set back from the road so this creates a large front yard perfect for putting up a volleyball net and playing with the family. We have ladder golf and croquet available per your request. We are on a busy road. The cottage is set back from it, but you will have to be careful letting young children run around.

We have 2 kayaks for your use. There is a local marina where you can rent a boat for the week. We can give you more information if you are interested in that option.

We love it here and hope you will too! Please contact me with any questions. We would love to also know more about you so please have details in your profile! It's a family cottage and we have neighbors close by so we need to be respectful of that.

  • do NOT contact me with unsolicited services or offers

post id: 6883918227



best of [?]